Help To Buy Vs First Home Guarantee: Which Is Better?

The Labor opposition party recently announced a Help To Buy scheme to make it easier for low- and middle-income home buyers to get onto the property ladder. If Labor wins the election, the party has pledged this scheme would go into effect in addition to its Regional First Home Buyer Support Scheme and the Coalition government’s First Home Guarantee.

Let’s find out what each of these schemes offers and which one is better for you.


Labor’s Help To Buy Scheme

Visual representation of help to buy scheme with a real-life scenario
The Help To Buy Scheme allows home buyers to purchase with a 2% deposit with paying Lenders Mortgage Insurance. Here are the basic details:

  • The government pays a large portion of the price of the home and retains ownership of that portion – up to 40% for new homes or 30% for existing homes.
  • Homeowners would not pay rent on the portion of their home the government owns.
  • The homeowner eventually would buy the government’s portion, either during the term of the loan or when they sell the house.

Liberal’s First Home Guarantee

The First Home Guarantee (formerly known as the First Home Loan Deposit Scheme), helps first home buyers with a deposit as low as 5% buy a home without paying Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI). Under this scheme, the government does not own a stake in the home, rather, it acts as guarantor for up to 15% of the value of the property.

The First Home Guarantee is one of the plans under the Coalition’s Home Guarantee Scheme. The other schemes are the family home guarantee for single parents with dependants and the Regional Home Guarantee buying in regional areas.

Note that not all lenders will be participating in all schemes. Home Loan Experts brokers can connect you with a participating lender with whom you can qualify for a place. Call us on 1300 889 743 or complete our free assessment form today!

Details Help To Buy First Home Guarantee
Who proposed it? Australian Labor Party (ALP), under Anthony Albanese The Coalition Government, under Scott Morrison
When will it apply? From 1 July 2022, if the ALP wins the election First Home Guarantee is already in effect. However, from 1 July 2022, price caps will increase and more places will be available.
What is it? It is a shared equity scheme where the government contributes 40% for new builds and 30% for existing properties. It is a guarantor scheme where the government acts as a mortgage insurer and guarantees up to 15% of the property value so that borrowers do not have to pay Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI).
What is the minimum deposit? 2% 5%
How many places are available?* 10,000 places each year* 35,000 places each year*
Is it only for first home buyers? No. It’s available for anyone who does not own property Yes.
Who can apply? Australian citizens Australian citizens
What is the income cap? Single applicants with an annual taxable income of less than $90,000 or less than $120,000 for couples Single applicants with an annual taxable income of less than $125,000 or less than $200,000 for couples
What are the benefits of the scheme? You get into the market sooner with a smaller loan, which equates to smaller repayments and less interest.

You do not need to pay rent on the portion of the property owned by the government.
You get into the market sooner and don’t need to pay LMI.

You own 100% of the home. The government does not have a stake in your property.
What are the disadvantages of the scheme? The government owns a portion of your property, which you have to buy back while you own the home or when you sell it. A larger loan, which means higher repayments and you pay more interest over the life of the loan.

*Note: Labor plans to run Help to Buy alongside the First Home Guarantee and its Regional First Home Buyer Support Scheme, so the total combined number of places under Labor would include all of those schemes.


Help To Buy Vs First Home Guarantee: Which Is Better For Me?

Which of these two schemes would serve you best depends on your particular situation. Let’s take a closer look. Remember that Labor’s plan will go into effect only if it wins the election in May 2022.

If you can afford only a small deposit

If saving a large deposit is difficult for you, then Help to Buy is the better plan. It requires only a 2% deposit, compared with 5% for the First Home Guarantee.

If you have a relatively low income

For potential buyers at the lower end of the income scale, Help to Buy is designed to offer a better chance at owning a home. The income caps are lower than for the First Home Guarantee, you can borrow a smaller portion of the price of the property, and the amount you pay over the life of the loan will be lower. The tradeoff is that the government owns a portion of your home and a proportionate share of your equity. If your income level rises, or you otherwise become able to pay the government for its stake, then you can eventually own the entire home and keep all your equity.

If competition for places if fierce

The First Home Guarantee has many more places for the coming financial year (35,000 to just 10,000) if you need to be in one of these two plans, you have more chances there than with Help to Buy. However, Labor has pledged to make the First Home Guarantee available as well.

If your focus is on retaining your equity

Equity is a huge benefit of homeownership and it is important to try to maximise it, whether you are an owner-occupier or you’re buying an investment property. In the First Home Guarantee, the government never has a stake in your home, so you benefit from 100% of any equity gains. In the Help to Buy scheme, the government can own as much as a 40% stake in your equity (in exchange for paying an equal proportion of the price of the property). But if it allows you to get onto the property ladder, partial equity may be better than nothing.

Home Loan Experts Tip

Striking a balance between a larger share of the equity and a lower total cost to the buyer may be a good choice for some home buyers. For example, say a home buyer pays the required 2% and gets the government to pay 18% – just enough to avoid Lenders Mortgage Insurance – rather than the maximum 30%-40%. This way, the home buyer still saves 18% of the cost of the property and retains an 82% share of the equity in the home, as opposed to just 60%-70%. This may be an especially good idea for buyers who anticipate earning a larger income later on.


Which Scheme Offers Higher Price Caps

Region Price Caps For Help To Buy Price Caps For First Home Guarantee
NSW – capital city & regional centres $950,000 $900,000
NSW – rest of state $600,000 $750,000
VIC – capital city & regional centre $850,000 $800,000
VIC – rest of state $550,000 $650,000
QLD – capital city & regional centre $650,000 $700,000
QLD – rest of state $500,000 $550,000
WA – capital city $550,000 $600,000
WA – rest of state $400,000 $450,000
SA – capital city $550,000 $600,000
SA – rest of state $400,000 $450,000
TAS – capital city $550,000 $600,000
TAS – rest of state $400,000 $450,000
ACT $600,000 $750,000
NT $550,000 $600,000

The scheme with the higher price cap is in bold. Besides the capital cities and regional centres of NSW and Victoria, the First Home Guarantee offers higher price caps for the other cities and the remaining areas of the states.


Coalition’s Super Home Buyer Scheme

The Coalition proposed the Super Home Buyer Scheme ahead of the federal election in May 2022. It is designed to help first-home buyers purchase a home sooner by using part of their super as a deposit. The plan will go into effect only if the Coalition wins re-election. You can get all the details of the scheme here.


We Can Help You Secure A Place

Labour’s Help To Buy Scheme and Liberal’s First Home Guarantee offer different benefits and price caps for home buyers. Whichever scheme goes into effect, our mortgage brokers can help you get approved for a home loan. Call us on 1300 889 743 or complete our free assessment form.

Why use us?

We aim to set an example by delivering what we promise: a higher level of service, better advice and better home loans.

pin_drop

Australia-wide services

We finance properties anywhere in Australia for people anywhere in the world.

monetization_on

Get incredible interest rates

Our relationships with our panel of lenders allow us to negotiate your interest rate.

thumb_up

We get tough loans approved

We can help you navigate the often complex pre-approval and application process.

favorite

Our customers love us

We receive hundreds of love letters from our customers.

Discover more reasons to use Home Loan Experts

How we find you the right solution

We get a complete understanding of where you’re at and what your ultimate goals are.
You’ll get a recommendation in just a few simple steps.

free assessment
1

Complete our free assessment form or call us.

situation
2

We assess your situation.

options
3

We look at all the options from our panel of lenders.

suitable home loan deals
4

We will find you the most suitable home loan deals.

Testimonials for Home loan experts

Facts
about us

50+

lenders on
our panel

$4B+

lent Australia-wide
and counting

Westpac
ANZ
Nab
AMP
Qudos
Firstmac
Common Wealth
St George
ING
Homeloans
Macquire
Suncorp
Pepper Money
Me Bank
Bankwest
75%

of our borrowers get
approved with a major bank

95%

of our borrowers get a discount
below the bank standard variable rate